How should we assess the doctrine of the mean in aristotles moral philosophy. Aristotles doctrine of the mean, a fundamental tenet of his system of ethics, also permeates his treatment of rhetorical theory. The practical import of aristotle s doctrine of the mean 3 trivial and obvious4 platitudinous and a practical futility barnes, 26. The archer and aristotles doctrine of the mean peitho. Aristotle on teaching examines teaching in general, and analyzes the objects, procedures, and order found in all student learning, furnishing the guidelines for the culminating section on the inductive and deductive procedures underlying all teaching. It explores aristotle s doctrine to discover its relevance for the art of teaching, defined as. Nicomachean ethics, helps to explain this circular, and in some ways puzzling, tension between having a nature and giving an account of ones nature. According to aristotle, each of the virtues of character. In the eudemian ethics and the nicomachean ethics,2 aristotle argues that excellence lies in a mean state mesotes, and from that point on the mean becomes a. Aristotle sviews on virtue are bound up with one of the most celebrated and least useful parts of his system, the doctrine of the mean, according to which every virtue of character lies between two correlative faults or vices, which consist respectively of the excess and the deficiency of something of which the virtue represents the. It not only ackrill finds aristotle s division of quality at best unmotivated. Aristotles doctrine of the mean introduction to ethics. According to aristotle s ethical rule about the golden mean, to use a thing with virtue is a kind of moderation, as it leads the particular thing being in a good condition, and allows for its functions to be performed in a proper manner. Aristotle s categories is a singularly important work of philosophy.
The matter will become clear, aristotle says, if we consider the. Pdf download aristotle on teaching full books pdfbooks. Aristotles the doctrine of the mean philosophy essay. J 1969, physiological theory and the doctrine of the mean in plato and aristotle, loyola university press, chicago. By human virtue we mean not that of the body but that of the soul.
Pdf it is sometimes claimed that aristotles doctrine of the mean is false or unhelpful. Proceedings of the aristotelian society, new series, vol. This essay examines whether aristotles doctrine of the mean is useful for making moral decisions and concludes that it is, but under a fundamentally different framework than those demanded by either utilitarian or kantian deontological ethics. Aristotle s doctrine of the mean, as it is found in the. An interpretation of the passage would be that at any given virtue lies between two extremes, either excess or deficient of, and the means between the two extremes determined by our rational principle. Portuguese version of what use is aristotles d octrine of the mean. A virtue then would be the intermediate between the two extremes, individually distinct from the two extremes by. Aristotles doctrine of the mean and its relationship to rhetoric. The practical import of aristotles doctrine of the mean. Aristotles doctrine of the mean and the circularity of. The men who introduced this doctrine did not posit ideas of classes within which they. In sections iiii i bring together various things aristotle says in developing his view that virtue or excellence lies in the observance of a mean.
940 583 815 129 1132 90 1319 185 590 999 64 605 588 794 335 537 500 815 741 1552 828 219 728 478 831 651 1105 1190 1317 1085 1075 458 279